• Reset your password

User account menu

  • Log in
Home
Image not available
Andreu Sulé

Main navigation

  • Home
  • What are my publications?
  • Who I am?
  • What I research?
  • What I teach?
  • Contact

RDA

Breadcrumb

  • Home

Is RDA really necessary?

By sule | 1:08 PM CEST, Fri September 02, 2016

Is RDA really necessary?

Image not available
Hello,

“The rules called Resource Description & Access (RDA) are an expensive answer to a non-existent problem.” These are not my own words but Michael Gorman, the reputed British-born librarian, in his last article RDA: the Emperor’s New Code published in JLIS.it (Vol. 7, No. 2, 2016).

It’s known the Gorman’s animosity towards RDA even since their first drafts. In RDA: the coming cataloguing debacle Gorman already showed himself “horrified” by them.

Someone can guess that this hostility has some relationship with his strong link with the Anglo-American cataloguing rules, the cataloging rules that RDA is called to substitute (Gorman was the first editor of AACR2 second edition at 1978 and 1988), but if we read carefully RDA: the Emperor’s New Code we can find serious and well-argued arguments.

His central idea is that ACCR2 is a cataloguing rule that “could accommodate useful change; and was perfectly adequate to the realities of modern cataloguing”. To demonstrate it, Gorman refers to the MRIs: AACR2 Rule Interpretations, a draft of unofficial AACR2 that incorporates all the changes produced in RDA.

After that, Gorman exemplifies the senseless of the cataloguing code change in three items: the “inexplicable and irresponsible” abandon of the ISBD, “the most successful bibliographic standard in history”; the right decision to abandon abbreviations in catalogue records, but that “could easily have been accommodated within AACR2”; and, by last, the fact that RDA “makes both cataloguing and catalogue use more confusing” because of the amount of “errors, confusions, misleading examples, and unclear wordings” that the code includes.

All in all, you can agree or not Gorman’s arguments, but it’s difficult to be indifferent about his opinions.

Enjoy it!

Andreu Sulé

University of Barcelona

RDA
Michael Gorman
  • Read more about Is RDA really necessary?
Subscribe to RDA

categories

Search engines 1
Discovery tools 1
Libraries 8
Smartwatches 1
User interfaces 1
Web Usability 1
Education 1
Research 2
Seminars 1
Responsive web design 1
Google Glass 1
Semantic Web 4
Books 1
Cataloguing 1
Search 1
BOBCATSSS 2015 2
Conference 1
Information 1
Documentation 1
Lib 1
Sustainability 1
Google 2
SERP 1
Almetrics 1
OCLC 2
Library of Congress 1
linked data 6
Facultat de Biblioteconomia i Documentació 2
Big data 2
Marshall Breeding 1
NISO 1
Discovery technologies 1
Web pages 1
Ranking 1
III International Seminar on LIS Education and Research 1
Schema.org 1
Apple Watch 1
UX 1
Interfaces design 1
Entity linking 1
Drupal 1
Agri SA 1
Glòria Pérez-Salmerón 1
IFLA 1
Democracy 1
LodView 1
National Library of the Netherlands 1
ESWC 2016 1
Big Data Congress 1
Startup Grind Barcelona 1
Start-ups 1
Catalonia 1
Google Search 1
App 1
Metadata 1
Publishers 1
European Data Portal 1
Open data 1
Visual Genome 1
Imatges 1
Reconeixement automàtic 1
Intel·ligència artificial 1
Images 1
Deep learning 1
Artificial intelligence 1
RDF 2
Digital collections 1
Spain 1
Libhub Initiative 1
Zepheira 1
BIBFRAME 1
Catalogues 1
RDA 1
Michael Gorman 1
International Council on Archives 1
Archival description 1
Standards 1
BOBCATSSS 2017 1

Footer menu

  • Contact

Copyright © 2025 Andreu Sule - All rights reserved